by shimp scrampi » Fri Jul 27, 2007 4:09 pm
I wonder if the Mary Kelly (or Don Wilson, etc) "fat" jokes don't sound a lot crueler to our 21st century ears than they did in the '30s and '40s.
Jack's pennypinching or Gracie Allen's lunatic logic - and the humor that surrounds them are basically wildly exaggerated traits that the audience can empathize with (you know, I'd save a buck like that if I could get away with it or gee, sometimes I think like that too). On a broad level, the "fat" jokes might be seen this way as well.
During a depression and on the verge of a war that had already started in Europe, the idea of ribbing someone who had the comparative luxury of some extra weight on the bones was different then. Being "fat" was probably a lot less of a negative than our current cultural "programming" makes it out to be - where if you aren't anorexic (particularly for women), something's got to be wrong.
I'm always shocked at the "Ironized Yeast" ads on Lights Out, those helpful pills that will help you pack on the weight. Certainly not the kind of product that's going to make a fortune in infomercial sales in 2007.
The point being, times change, and what was good-natured humor then can sound nasty to the point of being out of character for Jack or Gracie.
