IJBFC Chat - Febuary 15, 2015
(Name of message originator in the left-hand column)
Laura Leff | 2:02 PM | ||||
Hi Osa! | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:03 PM | ||||
Hi, Laura! I'm freezin' my hiney off here in Chicago! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:03 PM | ||||
Yow! I won't make you mad by telling you the weather here! | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:04 PM | ||||
Oh, go ahead . . . I'll enjoy hearing | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:04 PM | ||||
It looks like it's been pretty bad...I have a freiend in Boston who was updating me yesterday. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:04 PM | ||||
It's been unusually warm here...sunny too. It was in the 70s yesterday, and that's high for this time of year in Northern California. | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:05 PM | ||||
Arghhh! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:06 PM | ||||
Hey, you asked for it. | |||||
![]() |
|||||
Osa Buchner | 2:06 PM | ||||
Yep! Well, this is my first time in the chatroom. | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:07 PM | ||||
How many folks usually take part? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:07 PM | ||||
Usually more than this...but I imagine people are just now starting to sign up for their login, etc. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:08 PM | ||||
I try to get people to test it beforehand, but few ever do. | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:08 PM | ||||
Oh, OK. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:08 PM | ||||
I figured I'd test a different time, but I'm wondering if some may have forgotten. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:09 PM | ||||
I just put a blurb on the Facebook page. | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:09 PM | ||||
I figured out to put this on my Google calendar, so I got a nice reminder. Maybe folks are still out celebrating Jack's birthday! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:09 PM | ||||
Maybe! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:09 PM | ||||
Did you get a chance to listen to the show for tonight? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:10 PM | ||||
I guess at this time, I can't say tonight any more. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:11 PM | ||||
So what's your background with Jack? How did you get interested in him? | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:11 PM | ||||
I'm sorry, I didn't listen to the show, but I'll try to talk about anything you want. Maybe it was an episode I've heard before. Those podcasts of the Benny shows are terrific. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:12 PM | ||||
It's the episode of Jak's birthday with the Colmans and Isaac Stern. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:12 PM | ||||
Jack has a dinner at his house, and a pot and pan salesman shows up and offers them a free dinner. | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:13 PM | ||||
Been a fan for many years. His TV shows are great but nothing beats the radio shows. Absolutely brilliant. Wow, sorry I missed that episode! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:14 PM | ||||
Well, I'll still have it up on the Web site. You can listen to it over the coming month! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:14 PM | ||||
Do you have a favorite episode? | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:15 PM | ||||
I esp. like the Christmas episode where he keeps shocking himself with the Christmas lights: "Pull it out! Pull it out!" | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:15 PM | ||||
Ah yes...one of the military base shows! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:16 PM | ||||
Have you seen any of Jack's movies? | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:16 PM | ||||
BTW, someone should give you an award for all you do to keep Benny's legacy going. | |||||
HipChat | 2:16 PM | ||||
Hi @MashaDjivuljski! Welcome to Hipchat. You can @-mention me by typing @HipChat and I'll tell you what HipChat can do! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:16 PM | ||||
Thanks so much! Hey, just seeing people enjoying Jack's humor is a fantastic reward! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:16 PM | ||||
Hello Masha? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:17 PM | ||||
That was supposed to be an "!" | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:17 PM | ||||
Sorry that it's a small crowd at the moment...we'll see who else shows up! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:18 PM | ||||
Kind of funny as there's a gag in tonight's show about a bunch of telegrams from people telling Jack they can't attend his party. | |||||
Masha Djivuljski | 2:18 PM | ||||
Hi! Wow, my first time here! I live in Europe, so it's usually too late for me to join you. | |||||
![]() |
|||||
Osa Buchner | 2:18 PM | ||||
I liked "GW Slept Here" Some years ago I met someone working on a book about Ann Sheridan. I wonder if she ever finished the book | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:19 PM | ||||
Hi, Masha! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:19 PM | ||||
Welcome Masha! That's a good point...sometimes we've had night owls in Europe join us, or folks in Australia! | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:20 PM | ||||
I | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:20 PM | ||||
That's definitely one of his better movies. Have you seen To Be or Not To Be? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:21 PM | ||||
Tell us about yourself, Masha. How did you get interested in Jack? | |||||
Masha Djivuljski | 2:21 PM | ||||
Love that one. Saw it on the big screen at our local cinematheque last year... One of my favorite comedies for sure. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:21 PM | ||||
Oh wow...I've never seen it on the big screen (any bigger than my own television, which is still respectable). | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:22 PM | ||||
Speaking of Europe, there's an ENORMOUS poster for the 1960s Belgian release of the movie over on my left at the moment. Needs to be put on the wall. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:22 PM | ||||
Osa - Do you remember if that person had any comments about the connection between Ann Sheridan and Jack? There are some stories there. | |||||
HipChat | 2:23 PM | ||||
Hi @YhtapMys! Welcome to Hipchat. You can @-mention me by typing @HipChat and I'll tell you what HipChat can do! | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:24 PM | ||||
Yes, TBONTB is a great film. No, I didn't talk to that lady about Ann and Jack. We met years ago in the Warner Bros. library were we were researching our various projects. I always thought Sheridan was very beautiful, with a sultry voice | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:24 PM | ||||
Yht! You made it in! Assuming you're the same Yhtapmys | |||||
Masha Djivuljski | 2:24 PM | ||||
I think it started with Bob Hope... Somehow I came across one of his radio shows (probably one of my favorite classic stars was a guest) and then I kinda got sucked into old time radio programs. When I stumbled upon Jack, there was no going back! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:24 PM | ||||
A lot of people agree with you, Osa! | |||||
Masha Djivuljski | 2:25 PM | ||||
IMO Sheridan was underrated as an actress. Loved her with Cagney... He wrote nice things about her, too. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:25 PM | ||||
Hi, Laura. I had to fake it a bit to keep the name. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:25 PM | ||||
They won't let me use one word. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:25 PM | ||||
There's a story that there were rumors that Jack and Ann were more than friends during the filming of that movie (and IIRC, Sheridan was known for enjoying the company of a number of men). | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:26 PM | ||||
Yht - You know, I hadn't even thought about that since I always go by my own name! | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:26 PM | ||||
Benny also got me interested in the great Elliot Lewis. BTW, would anybody know where I could find photos of Lewis from the 1980s? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:26 PM | ||||
Hmmm...I'm wondering if SPERDVAC might have something for you. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:27 PM | ||||
Do you know about the Old Radio Digest? It doesn't have nearly the traffic that it used to, but it still has a lot of knowledgeable people who get it. | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:27 PM | ||||
Wow, I never kknew that Benny and Sheridan might have had a thing | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:27 PM | ||||
Also you can post something on our Facebook IJBFC page...I bet someone there can help you. | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:27 PM | ||||
Great ideas. Thanks, Laura! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:28 PM | ||||
Well, those were the rumors. And supposedly Mary walked up to Ann at a party and said loudly to her, "I have more sex appeal in my little finger than you do in your whole body!" | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:28 PM | ||||
And stormed off. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:29 PM | ||||
So any thoughts on the episode for today's discussion? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:29 PM | ||||
Jack's birthday party with the Colmans and Isaac Stern. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:30 PM | ||||
Have to fire it up to remember which one it is. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:30 PM | ||||
Well, more generally...what questions do you have about Jack? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:30 PM | ||||
Or Benny topics you'd like to explore. | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:31 PM | ||||
I'm sure you've been asked dozens or times, but did you ever meet him? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:31 PM | ||||
Nope. I was only 5 when he died, and I wasn't quite into him yet! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:32 PM | ||||
But yet it doesn't seem to stop folks from thinking that he's my father. They know I'm not Joan, though. | |||||
Masha Djivuljski | 2:32 PM | ||||
How did you get into him? Sorry, if you've been asked that before... | |||||
![]() |
|||||
HipChat | 2:32 PM | ||||
Hi @JosefSilvia! Welcome to Hipchat. You can @-mention me by typing @HipChat and I'll tell you what HipChat can do! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:32 PM | ||||
Hi Josef! | |||||
Josef Silvia | 2:32 PM | ||||
Hello Laura! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:32 PM | ||||
Welcome in...glad you made it! | |||||
Josef Silvia | 2:32 PM | ||||
Me too! Been a while | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:33 PM | ||||
Laura, have you heard anything from/about Jeanette Eyeman lately? | |||||
HipChat | 2:33 PM | ||||
Hi @MarcThorner! Welcome to Hipchat. You can @-mention me by typing @HipChat and I'll tell you what HipChat can do! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:33 PM | ||||
Well, the full story is on our FAQ. For chat purposes, it was The Mouse that Jack Built cartoon that first piqued my interest. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:33 PM | ||||
Hey Marc! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:33 PM | ||||
Now here comes everyone! | |||||
Marc Thorner | 2:33 PM | ||||
Hey, it woiks!!! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:33 PM | ||||
Yht - No, although I did get a new address for her. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:33 PM | ||||
Yes, hopefully better than our prior chat providers! | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:33 PM | ||||
This is like the daylight saving time episode. No one knows when it's on. | |||||
|
|||||
Laura Leff | 2:34 PM | ||||
Should I have sent out a reminder? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:34 PM | ||||
Didn't want anyone to feel spammed. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:35 PM | ||||
So who's snowed in? I know Osa is. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:35 PM | ||||
I am not. | |||||
Josef Silvia | 2:35 PM | ||||
I am. Boston is pretty much shut down today. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:35 PM | ||||
To be honest, I can't keep track. I'm so used to 1st Sundays at 5 but either it's not then any more or I'm away (or sleeping) when it is. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:36 PM | ||||
No snow by Mary's old place. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:36 PM | ||||
Yeah, I was on the phone with Marty (my writing partner) is visiting Boston and gave me the lowdown yesterday. | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:36 PM | ||||
I'm so sorry about that, Josef. Hope you're safe and warm | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:36 PM | ||||
So what thoughts on the show for discussion today? | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:36 PM | ||||
Surprised to hear John Brown. Was he in L.A. doing a Riley movie? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:37 PM | ||||
Could be...but I thought John Brown showed up occasionally. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:38 PM | ||||
When Allen had his sabbatical in 1943-44, yes. I didn't realise he was as late at 1947. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:38 PM | ||||
It was ironic that Radio Spirits sent out an ad today with a picture of him with William Bendix, and then here he is on today's show. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:38 PM | ||||
Right...Jack was employing a few of Fred's regulars, including Minerva Pious. | |||||
Josef Silvia | 2:38 PM | ||||
Was wondering about that | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:39 PM | ||||
Did the Colmans ever do a bad show? I like all of them. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:39 PM | ||||
Jack hardly ever did a bad show. I agree that all the ones with the Colmans are gems. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:39 PM | ||||
You're right...he's on frequently 1943-44, and then once in 1945 and this one show from 1947. Then no more. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:40 PM | ||||
Well, some of the mid-30s are a little trying. Harry Conn wasn't above hokum. | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:40 PM | ||||
Did the Colmans have any kids? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:40 PM | ||||
I had forgotten that Jack and Mary did the "Oh shut up" gag more than once with Dorothy Kirsten. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:41 PM | ||||
Yes, they had a daughter. She wrote a book about them, and I excerpted it in a recent newsletter. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:41 PM | ||||
Yht - Heck, Conn practically *was* hokum in hindsight. | |||||
Josef Silvia | 2:41 PM | ||||
Oh wow. I really need to re-subscribe to the newsletter | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:41 PM | ||||
In fact, I have a script on his letterhead on the desk next to me with his rewrites on it, and it's not that great. | |||||
HipChat | 2:42 PM | ||||
Hi @KathyFullerSeeley! Welcome to Hipchat. You can @-mention me by typing @HipChat and I'll tell you what HipChat can do! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:42 PM | ||||
I need to do another back issues edition, but between watching paint dry and indexing, I'll take the former. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:42 PM | ||||
Hi Kathy! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:42 PM | ||||
I'm trying to remember...have you ever been in the chat room previously? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:43 PM | ||||
So what else about today's program? | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:43 PM | ||||
Still odd hearing Jack is 38. | |||||
Josef Silvia | 2:43 PM | ||||
Yes. When did he start saying 39? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:43 PM | ||||
And hey Kathy...can you give everyone the lowdown on the book on which you've been working? I'm sure folks will be interested. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:44 PM | ||||
Jack bounced around on his age in the early days. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:44 PM | ||||
Hey Laura, was quick catching up on the coversation. I always love your Jack cartoon story because I think its the same way I got hooked, haha | |||||
Josef Silvia | 2:44 PM | ||||
He was 37 for a whie, if I remember correctly | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:45 PM | ||||
That's correct | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:45 PM | ||||
oh and thank you for asking about the book -- I am only one introduction and one conclusion away from having the whole draft done!!! A really nice editor at Oxford Unviersity Press books is meeting with me at our professors-film-studies conference next month to talk about making it a book, hooray! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:45 PM | ||||
Kathy - Apparently that cartoon makes us fall pretty hard for Jack! | |||||
Josef Silvia | 2:46 PM | ||||
And didn't Ronald Colman say the same joke about Mary before? About how she got mixed up with that bunch of shlamiels. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:46 PM | ||||
I don't think Jack ever played a teenage-wet-behind the ears fellow., hahaha he was always adult headed toward getting older | |||||
HipChat | 2:46 PM | ||||
Hi @KatiePerry! Welcome to Hipchat. You can @-mention me by typing @HipChat and I'll tell you what HipChat can do! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:46 PM | ||||
Fantastic! I apologize for not giving you feedback on the chapter you shared a long time ago, and then I figured you had probably edited it eventually. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:46 PM | ||||
Hi Katie! | |||||
Katie Perry | 2:46 PM | ||||
Hi Laura! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:47 PM | ||||
Tell folks what the book is about, Kathy. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:47 PM | ||||
For me, it was that darn cartoon and a book on American culture in the 1930s, one of those Time-Life series books. They had a chapter on radio. I saw a photo of Jack and Fred going at it, and that sold me. Spent all my babysitting money to buy one or two cassette tapes at a time. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:48 PM | ||||
I never did babysitting, but sounds like me for certain! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:48 PM | ||||
Ah ha, the book is about Jack's radio career. I am impressed with how multi-talented he was, as an editor/writer, as a performer, a genius marekter/advertiser. | |||||
Josef Silvia | 2:48 PM | ||||
Oh wow! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:48 PM | ||||
He was also called the biggest celebrity in Hollywood by 1936, as tourists could go hear his show but could not see actual movie stars or movies being made | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:49 PM | ||||
There's a gag about Jack being 39 as early as 4/19/36. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:49 PM | ||||
That would have been true for other shows as well...I guess Jack's was the most popular with out-of-towners. | |||||
![]() |
|||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:49 PM | ||||
So its eight chapters, one whole chapter is about Mary's character and her as a performer (we may think she's ill tempered and whatever, but the character is pretty unique even among the Katharine Hepburns/Ginger Rogers/Eve Arden types | |||||
Josef Silvia | 2:49 PM | ||||
Really Laura? Guess he was trying to find which number was the funniest one to stick with | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:50 PM | ||||
two chapters on Eddie Anderson - can you believe there's never been a whole book about him? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:50 PM | ||||
Josef - There was no effort for consistency back then. His age skipped around until 1949. | |||||
Josef Silvia | 2:50 PM | ||||
Gotcha. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:50 PM | ||||
Kathy - Yeah, I believe that because he's so darn enigmatic. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:50 PM | ||||
Don too. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:50 PM | ||||
one on the big slump Benny's show entered in 1944-1945 and the rise of sharp radio critics like John Crosby who helped goad Benny into making it back to the top by 1946 | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:50 PM | ||||
Eddie Anderson was a real patriot, I understand. With that parachute company he started. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:50 PM | ||||
Eddie was a colorful character in private life, but it's hard to find hard facts on him. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:51 PM | ||||
Osa - Ah, that's correct! I hadn't thought about that in a while. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:51 PM | ||||
you got it about Eddie being enigmatic, I read everything I could find in the black press about him, and he would NEVER spill the beans about what it was really like | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:51 PM | ||||
Kathy - I'm glad you're devoting good space to him. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:51 PM | ||||
Kathy - Exactly. You can get the press stories, but it doesn't show you the reality. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:52 PM | ||||
its really interesting about how young liberals in the black community tried to rag on Eddie the same way that they were piling on to Hattie McDaniel for playing mammies. Jack offered very useful protection. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:53 PM | ||||
Yes, and as we all know, Roch was different. He may have called Jack "Boss" because they didn't want to lose their southern stations. But they interacted on more of a peer level. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:53 PM | ||||
Laura, I can't wait to learn more about your Buck Benny find!!! Just the fact that Jack earned $125K and Eddie $8K is mind-blowing. Paramount through a whole separate premiere of the film in Harlem, spent boodles of money that they didn't give Eddie in salary... | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:53 PM | ||||
It must have been very hard for Anderson, just to practice his craft as an artist. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:54 PM | ||||
Poor Eddie got it from both sides. Racist whites in the south started banning his films in 1945, like Brewster's Millions, saying he was too "familiar" with whites | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:54 PM | ||||
Well, remember that he had joined the Benny cast in 1937, and then was sporadic until (IIRC without looking it up) the fall when he took on the Rochester character. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:54 PM | ||||
you are right, Osa, it was incredibly hard, and Eddie deserves lots of respect for doing his best in a difficult situation that could not please everyone | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:54 PM | ||||
And Rochester wasn't even on regularly for a while. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:54 PM | ||||
I would have to look it up, but Eddie was only a couple years into his tenure with Jack by the filming of Buck Benny. | |||||
Osa Buchner | 2:55 PM | ||||
Have to log off now, but I REALLY enjoyed this chatroom! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:55 PM | ||||
If you ever get to look at Mark Sandrich's papers at the Herrick Library in LA, there is some great stuff about it was HIS idea to make Eddie's part in Man About Town grow. They rode it all the way to the bank, that film was a monster success, all due to Eddie | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:55 PM | ||||
Oh and how about that...someone (a friend of mine, not even a member of the IJBFC) found the story that tells where the episode happened of Jack moving the cast because a hotel wouldn't host Rochester? | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:55 PM | ||||
! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:56 PM | ||||
Yeah, as many of you know, I *LOVE* Man About Town. I think it's a great movie. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:56 PM | ||||
I think that story must be true, Laura, Jim Crow laws were terrible and Jack was good about being progressive! | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:56 PM | ||||
WB Katie | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:56 PM | ||||
Laura, that wasn't at the Sherry Netherland, was it? | |||||
Josef Silvia | 2:56 PM | ||||
I need to see that movie | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:56 PM | ||||
According to the information my friend found, it was the Fairmont in San Francisco. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:57 PM | ||||
Ah, Sorry. I thought it was in NYC for some reason. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:57 PM | ||||
And what's ironic is that they suggested Eddie go to the Mark Twain hotel, and I dined there recently for the first time because another friend was a waiter there! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:57 PM | ||||
One thing that shocked me in watching Man about Town was Eddie's dance sequence when a big gorilla in a cage behind him starts moving in time w Eddie. Sandrich through it was a hoot and left it in the film. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:57 PM | ||||
Yht - I had always thought that too. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:57 PM | ||||
Kathy - You know, I'll have to look at that again! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:58 PM | ||||
On the other hand, there are great stories about Eddie's fame, have you all seen the stories where he was headed up to a Harvard smoker party and MIT students kidnapped him? | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:58 PM | ||||
this was when he was in NYC for the Buck Benny premiere. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:58 PM | ||||
Oh man...I haven't heard about that in so long I can't remember the details. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:58 PM | ||||
A clipping was posted on the forum some time ago, Laura. | |||||
Katie Perry | 2:58 PM | ||||
I was able to introduce my husband to Jack Benny and his favorite skit is jack explaining to Rochester a dessert that has to be flambé. I believe it was the english butler | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:59 PM | ||||
Can't remember when I put it there. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:59 PM | ||||
Yht - Thanks...I need to be more diligent in following our own Forum! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 2:59 PM | ||||
I've been collecting up all that stuff, will drop it into the facebook group sometime | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 2:59 PM | ||||
Well, it must have been six or seven years ago. | |||||
Laura Leff | 2:59 PM | ||||
Ah...that's why the details are faint for me. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:00 PM | ||||
I haven't reposted it at Tralfaz as I keep posting new material. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:00 PM | ||||
Katie - Have you got him hooked on Jack, or is he more of a casual secondhand listener? | |||||
![]() |
|||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:00 PM | ||||
So, I greatly appreciate the help of this great group while I've been working on this project! You all are the best. | |||||
Josef Silvia | 3:01 PM | ||||
Can't wait to read the book Kathy! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:01 PM | ||||
This week I get to talk about Jack in BOTH my undergrad courses, hooray! One class is on comedy, and I am working Jack into the roots of the sitcom | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:01 PM | ||||
Yes, the Facebook group is a great group of folks. Wonderful to be able to have people throw questions out there and have a lot of discussion on it. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:02 PM | ||||
Yht - I just want to say publcly that your posts on Tralfaz are great! | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:02 PM | ||||
Hmm. Jack fits in a Studebaker joke this week. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:02 PM | ||||
I don't know how long they'll continue, Laura. I've got them banked until the end of June. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:02 PM | ||||
My other class is a cultural history of advertising, and we are doing "branded entertainment." Ad industry folks think they've discovered something new in having advertisers sponsor and create whole programs. They have completely forgotten about radio, I;ll be doing Jell-O commercials, which always makes me hungry for it | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:02 PM | ||||
Yeah, I didn't have time to look that up. I presume it must have been a sales thing for their cars around then of "going both ways." | |||||
Katie Perry | 3:02 PM | ||||
Kathy: I would love to be able to take that class! | |||||
Laura: he's hooked, he certainly thought I was quite strange when we first started dating. Apparently, having an iPod w/ nothing but Jack Benny on it is not the norm. Lol | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:03 PM | ||||
Kathy - Oh man, I may have told you that I became OCD about Jell-O when I was writing Volume 1! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:03 PM | ||||
Oh yes the Tralfaz posts are wonderful!!!! Thank you for putting up the Benny summer radio show, it was such a gas to stumble upon that in Radio Mirror | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:03 PM | ||||
Laura, I'm sure you've seen the old Studebakers with the wrap-around windows. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:03 PM | ||||
Katie - Tell me about it. | |||||
![]() |
|||||
Laura Leff | 3:03 PM | ||||
Yht - Ah yes, I do remember those. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:04 PM | ||||
I can understand that completely, Laura. Don's intro and closing commercials are so darn "tasty" and the middles are so fun! Jell-O sure could use that kind of help now | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:04 PM | ||||
Kathy - You probably know most of everything we said, but you may want to take a look at Marty's essay in Volume 2. Jack's middle commercials is one of his big topics. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:04 PM | ||||
Kathy, what I liked discovering ... and most of the posts I put up are accidental discoveries .. was the dialogue from shows for which no recordings exist. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:04 PM | ||||
yep, that's a helpful piece. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:04 PM | ||||
Kathy - Would you believe that General Foods, last I was in touch with them, actually does remember their Benny roots! They were a sponsor of our 2003 convention. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:05 PM | ||||
Hey Kathy, didn't you say you were going to post all the 1932 scripts? | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:05 PM | ||||
Incidentally, State Farm also remembers its Benny roots. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:05 PM | ||||
well its my goal to get those unrecorded scripts up online. I think UCLA might let me take photos now, and if so, I will be getting them available for you all! There are such great bits!!! I am a fugitive from a happy chain gang! | |||||
Katie Perry | 3:05 PM | ||||
One thing that I love is the batman/robin Jack Benny comic. I stumbled across that last year and was impressed to see how Jack Benny truly was influential in so many mediums | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:06 PM | ||||
I don't think the switch to American Tobacco in '44 helped. Listeners were used to hearing Don opening the show with a friendly spot. When Luckies came on, listeners got 90 seconds of repetitious hard sell. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:06 PM | ||||
I was negotiating with UCLA to get them to scan all the Canada Dry scripts for me and publish them in a book, but then we could never get to a reasonable price. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:06 PM | ||||
Katie - Oh yeah, aren't those great? The guy who "rediscovered" that strip sent me the whole thing. It was a joy to read. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:06 PM | ||||
well Laura, I have a bunch of the NBC 1932 scripts and then 1933s and 1934s, I got these from the Library of Congress. I need to start a website where I can get the jpegs up. Do you have room on the IJBFC website to host some? | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:07 PM | ||||
Sure. I'd love to make those available! | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:07 PM | ||||
And one of Jack's grandkids has offered me all the disk space I want. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:07 PM | ||||
Yeah, Laura, UCLA wants TONS of money to scan things. More and more archives now are letting you take cell phone shots now. We will prevail, yet! | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:07 PM | ||||
I'd love to read the '32s. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:07 PM | ||||
Yeah...I think they were talking about a thousand dollars or something. | |||||
Josef Silvia | 3:07 PM | ||||
wow | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:07 PM | ||||
A thousand ooops!? | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:08 PM | ||||
Well it would be great fun, there is so much great stuff in the early 30s shows | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:08 PM | ||||
Jack's relationship with Mary in 1932 is particularly interesting to read. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:08 PM | ||||
haha 1000oops. They were talking six dollars for every PAGE I wanted to photocopy in 2012. Robberbarons... | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:08 PM | ||||
It's really cute and flirtatious, and she's such an ardent fan. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:08 PM | ||||
Yes, and when they profess their love for each other its so cute!!!! | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:08 PM | ||||
Ardent fan? Like Logan Jerkfinkle? | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:09 PM | ||||
Dang! I don't think the prices were ever that high for me. | |||||
HipChat | 3:09 PM | ||||
Hi @RogerKentCooper! Welcome to Hipchat. You can @-mention me by typing @HipChat and I'll tell you what HipChat can do! | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:09 PM | ||||
Kathy - OMG yes! That's just one of the sweetest scenes in the whole series! | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:09 PM | ||||
Hi Roger! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:09 PM | ||||
That show Jack had to do in early April 1936 when Harry left, where Jack and Mary say let's get married! is also cute | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:09 PM | ||||
Yht - Something like that. | |||||
Roger Kent Cooper | 3:09 PM | ||||
Hello everyone. First time for me for the chat. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:09 PM | ||||
Kathy - That's true. Or where Mary is looking at rings in a window, and Jack says, "I'll never wear it." | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:10 PM | ||||
This is great! We have a number of first-timers to the chat today. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:10 PM | ||||
oh yes! I love him as Mr Twink and she's mussing up his apron | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:10 PM | ||||
April '36. And he takes out an ad in Variety a month earlier pushing himself through his connection to the Benny show. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:10 PM | ||||
OK, I'll say it. Harry Conn was an egotistical fool. | |||||
Roger Kent Cooper | 3:10 PM | ||||
I live in East Peoria, IL Somewhere around 2 hrs and 30 minute drive from Waukegan. | |||||
Josef Silvia | 3:11 PM | ||||
I think that's an understandment | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:11 PM | ||||
well I have found some great stuff in Variety and the other trade papers, Conn was really doing the nasty to Jack. He had another ad agency all ready to set him up with his own show! | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:11 PM | ||||
Hey Kathy - I can't remember, did they scan all of the pages of the Harry Conn script that was on Ebay? It's on the desk next to me. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:11 PM | ||||
Karma got him. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:11 PM | ||||
no, I only saw a couple. what is the rest of the Conn script like? looked like spec for somebody? | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:11 PM | ||||
I almost wonder if Conn's departure had some of the same earmarks as Kenny's departure. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:12 PM | ||||
Kathy - It's got a lot of handwritten reworking on it. I haven't had the patience to read the whole thing, and it's only a few pages long. That tells you something. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:12 PM | ||||
well, Laura, I am going to reprint some of the correspondence between Jack and Harry in my chapter on their relationship. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:12 PM | ||||
Oh fascinating...you've probably seen stuff that I haven't yet. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:12 PM | ||||
I know about the angry telegram from Jack to Harry (IIRC). | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:13 PM | ||||
there's not much, but the four page long telegram is pretty amazing. Unless they tell me no, that whole thing goes in | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:13 PM | ||||
Yht - Oh man, you ain't kidding. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:13 PM | ||||
Who would tell you no, UCLA? | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:13 PM | ||||
If it's from the Library of Congress, isn't it public domain? | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:14 PM | ||||
I think because I am discussing it a lot, it will still be OK as "fair use" | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:15 PM | ||||
Oh, the telegram is in the Jack Benny papers, hidden back in a file with a bunch of contracts. Jack really did have a clause in Eddie's that fined him $50 for every 15 minutes he was late to rehearsals. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:15 PM | ||||
It's a wonder Eddie made any money. I bet Jack didn't enforce it haard. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:15 PM | ||||
I think I also spotted it in Don's contract, hahaha | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:15 PM | ||||
If UCLA gives you crap about using the telegram, get with me. I think I can get you Estate permission to use it. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:16 PM | ||||
Eddie was the highest-paid African American performer (on radio, tv or film, I can't vouch for music) up to the mid-1950s. He did OK, a sad commentary though on how little everyone else earned | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:17 PM | ||||
COOL, Laura, love to have you as my enforcer : ) | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:17 PM | ||||
Poitier hadn't appeared on the scene yet | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:17 PM | ||||
Kathy - I'm with ya, sistah! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:17 PM | ||||
So, Laura, what is the neatest Benny document in your own personal collection? | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:17 PM | ||||
Hmmm...depends on your point of view. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:18 PM | ||||
I have a similar flame letter that Jack wrote to George Balzer effectively firing him. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:18 PM | ||||
Jack's high school yearbooks are pretty cool | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:18 PM | ||||
oh boy! when old Jack gets mad....batten down the hatches... | |||||
Roger Kent Cooper | 3:18 PM | ||||
Hard to see Jack mad unless in character. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:19 PM | ||||
And they're sitting on top of a table that only two exist...someone made two prototypes of a card table with an extremely elaborate Buck Benny drawing on it. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:19 PM | ||||
Oh yeah, Jack could really let someone have it when he went off. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:19 PM | ||||
Joan owns the other table. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:20 PM | ||||
I think I've seen a photo of one of them, connected with Jell-0 sponsorship, that is amazing! | |||||
Josef Silvia | 3:20 PM | ||||
Why did Jack fire George Balzer? | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:20 PM | ||||
And I have a photo of Jack and Cora Salisbury from their touring days that has his inscription on the back saying "Compliments of Salisbury and Benny" | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:20 PM | ||||
Kathy - I put some photos of it up on the Facebook page back over Thanksgiving weekend of 2012. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:21 PM | ||||
Isaac Stern only got 2 1/2 mins. for his solo. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:21 PM | ||||
Josef - The basic thing was that he was behaving badly for various reasons. Seems like Hickey Marks was one of the main triggers. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:21 PM | ||||
hooray that facebook never erases anything, I will go look, haha | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:21 PM | ||||
Yht - Yeah...hard balance when you put long-haired music in a comedy show. (BTW, I'm a huge classical buff, so not talking it down.) | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:22 PM | ||||
Laura that sounds like a straightline about Hickey | |||||
Josef Silvia | 3:22 PM | ||||
Wasn't he with Jack for a while too, right? | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:22 PM | ||||
Kathy - Oh man, Hickey was the butt of every joke. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:22 PM | ||||
Josef - Who? | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:22 PM | ||||
It seems the Marks family could get pretty prickly. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:22 PM | ||||
They were an odd bunch. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:23 PM | ||||
The Variety stuff about Sid Silvers and Mary was something. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:23 PM | ||||
You get Babe doing her own "wrong door raid," you get all the stories about Hickey, and Mary goes without saying. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:23 PM | ||||
I give Jack creds for being loyal to all the Marks-es. Was it true that they used to go to the mother and father's house for buffet between the two shows? | |||||
Josef Silvia | 3:23 PM | ||||
George Balzer, wasn't he with Jack for a while? | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:23 PM | ||||
Kathy - Yes, in the 30s. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:23 PM | ||||
Oh I LOVE the way Variety claims that the Silvers flap was all Mary's doing! | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:23 PM | ||||
Josef - Yep. Started in 1943, and then up through about 1968. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:24 PM | ||||
Kathy - Have you seen the billings for her as "Jack's pest-girl"? | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:24 PM | ||||
It must have been a tough situation, Silvers had sold Benny vaudeville comedy material, and they worked together in like 1934 on Friars stuff and in Bway Melody of 1936? | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:25 PM | ||||
Well, remember how things unfolded with Conn. Jack still paid him when he used his gags, even when Conn was a backstage doorman. | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:25 PM | ||||
I presumed Jack had no hard feelings toward him, otherwise he wouldn't have been in the film with him. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:25 PM | ||||
And sometimes he paid him even when he didn't use his gags. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:25 PM | ||||
I don't know if Jack stayed permanently mad with anyone. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:25 PM | ||||
no I don't think "pest girl" but that is great! Mary was getting lots of press in 1934-1936, if you remember all the great newspaper spreads from Pittsburgh adn Detroit that are in Jack's scrapbooks., Contests to write back poems in Mary style and such | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:26 PM | ||||
Yeah, it's a phrase primarily used in the stage appearance clippings that I've found in Jack's scrapbooks. "Live on stage...Jack Benny with the Chicken Sisters and his pest-girl, Mary" | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:27 PM | ||||
Hey Katie, WB. Say, I remember you started as a young Benny fan. How did you first get into Jack? | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:27 PM | ||||
I found some great stuff about Conn's down fall. First they paid him much more than I think it was Joe Penner to do the first show, that bombed, then he was with Jack Haley for like a week. Funny and sad self-publicity Conn did with his own "Earaches of 1938" | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:27 PM | ||||
Kathy, are there any airchecks of Earaches that you know of? | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:27 PM | ||||
Hey, did you see the 1932 show where Conn effectively does Jack's role? | |||||
HipChat | 3:28 PM | ||||
Hi @MichaelAmowitz! Welcome to Hipchat. You can @-mention me by typing @HipChat and I'll tell you what HipChat can do! | |||||
Michael Amowitz | 3:28 PM | ||||
Jello folks! | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:28 PM | ||||
I'd have to look it up, but I remember him giving himself some big, overblown speech in it. It was pretty eye-rolling. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:28 PM | ||||
Hey Mike! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:28 PM | ||||
well I haven't looked. I do have the reviews from Variety and Billboard, I think, saying that its an exact replica of Jack's show, down to comic, girl pest and bandleader. The thing was a suicide mission, however, as it was scheduled opposite Charlie McCarthy | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:29 PM | ||||
Maybe they knew that, and figured it would be a throwaway. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:30 PM | ||||
"What should we put in this timeslot?" "I don't know, put any old crap in there. It's opposite Bergen and no one will listen anyway. Put organ music for all I care." | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:30 PM | ||||
Was it sustaining? | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:30 PM | ||||
Yes Laura, the 1932 show in New Orleans, when Jack is on the road, traveling down to get to them? Are we talking about the same one? They could have gotten run out of town on a rail for doing a version of Uncle Tom's Cabin... | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:30 PM | ||||
Yep, that's the one. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:30 PM | ||||
yes, Earaches was sustaining, CBS pulled it , I believe after 13 weeks when no sponsor showed up | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:31 PM | ||||
Can't imagine why... | |||||
![]() |
|||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:31 PM | ||||
from what I can piece together, Harry Conn was not good at actually delivering comic lines. He could write them, and he was a tap dancer.....although he sure thought he knew everything there was about timing | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:32 PM | ||||
the timing stuff I got from a couple snarky letters Conn wrote to Benny after leaving him in March 1936.....Conn is right, but I am sure Jack was not in the mood to hear it, at that point! | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:32 PM | ||||
So hard without the recordings. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:33 PM | ||||
You wonder what his point was. Was he just trying to rub Jack's nose in it, or did he have so much hubris that he thought he could pull all the stunts he did and then somehow get Jack to realize his so-called "grandeur?" | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:33 PM | ||||
does anybody have any General Foods/Jell-) related Benny material? I once saw some photos taken of grocery store displays with pictures of Jack | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:33 PM | ||||
How about the cookbook? | |||||
Michael Amowitz | 3:34 PM | ||||
Hi, LL, all, I've been catching up. Don't know the rest of the dirt about Conn, but looks like a mess! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:34 PM | ||||
Laura, I think it was some major nose-rubbing, haha Conn had been obsessing about how HE was the brains of the outfit and Benny merely the mouthpiece... | |||||
Yhtap Mys | 3:34 PM | ||||
Michael, Conn was a jerk. And a BSer. | |||||
Michael Amowitz | 3:35 PM | ||||
I've only known of him, don't think I'd ever heard him | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:35 PM | ||||
"My husband's brains paid for that coat." | |||||
Roger Kent Cooper | 3:35 PM | ||||
Is there any area of Jack Benny's career/life that could use some more research? | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:35 PM | ||||
"Oh really, sounds like I got the long end of the trade then!" | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:35 PM | ||||
Roger - I learn new stuff all the time. I call it the 80-year breadcrumb trail. | |||||
Roger Kent Cooper |
![]()
|
||||
Laura Leff | 3:36 PM | ||||
After doing this for 35 years, I think there's nowhere that we know "everything." | |||||
Roger Kent Cooper | 3:36 PM | ||||
I wonder being close to were JB grew up puts me in a good position to do some research? | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:36 PM | ||||
It just depends on what interests you. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:36 PM | ||||
Aha! | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:37 PM | ||||
Roger, I so agree with Laura, there are so many things left to discover, little bits of stuff in archives and private hands all over the country! | |||||
Michael Amowitz | 3:37 PM | ||||
I saw the audio link someone posted for a lost 1928 Jack & Mary movie. I haven't had time to run it; is it any good? | |||||
Roger Kent Cooper | 3:37 PM | ||||
I live by Peoria, IL so it would be cool to find out were JB performed and if any of those buisldings still stand. | |||||
Laura Leff | 3:37 PM | ||||
You know, if you're up for it, I'd love to have someone combing the vaudeville listings in the Midwestern papers in 1912-1917. I have a few of Jack and Cora's appearances, but they were playing such small time that most of them don't show up in Variety. | |||||
Kathy Fuller-Seeley | 3:37 PM | ||||
Oh Mike, its really interesting! He sounds like the Jack of 1932, and Mary sounds nervous, haha. Remember that this was the soundtrack to a very early talkie, so they do things that we can't see |